Strange main of RDR1 [possible spoilers] (Red Dead Redemption 2)

We all know the Strange man from the first part and his quests. If he could be Trelawney of the second part? The name in the first part he was not. In style they are very similar in both appearance and behavior. As we know Trelawney appears and disappears in the course of the narrative in the second part, and is a magician. Besides his sentence, John said: i seem to know you, you may suggest that he was once in the band van der Linde
What do you think about this?
P. S I know the photo is a Strange man can be found in one store and John will say that he is familiar.