The problem between the two players (FIFA 18)

Hello! Guys,please help me!! Play with one computer,I'm using the keyboard and the other using the joystick. Go to settings->control settings there in the settings of the controller, configurable auto-players help in assists, etc. the Essence of the problem: one of us comes into these settings and sets auto-manual(for example) and this setting must be applied to the controller under a number. Then comes another with another controller and he settings are those that I have set and when they change they change I have the same. Though the game sees that the settings vary for different controllers. How to make this setting separately for each ?