Poll: the Most atmospheric game?

Alien: Isolation

Max Payne1-2, Xenus1, Rogue Trooper, Mehanoids

It's a tough question, there are a lot of games.
Life Force
Zanac
Castlevania II - Simon's Quest
Rockman (1987)
Gimmick
Super Spy Hunter
Contra (1988)
Wai Wai World
Guardian Legend
Ninja Gaiden II - The Dark Sword of Chaos (1990)
Legend of Zelda (1986)
Lunar Pool
Super Mario Bros 2 (1988)

Imho
Bioshock infinitie
Tomb raider
Dead space 1

rust
how to survive
disonord
and of course the last thief

Atmosphere - the concept is subjective, and not many understand all aspects that make up the atmosphere in games.

1 Vampire Bloodlines
2 Gothic-3
3 Stalker

In Metro voiceover - the highest class, but there is no open world - minus.

My humble IMHO, here are three games that make me fall out of reality:
1. Vampire: the masqurade - Bloodlines
2. Silent hill 4,5
3. GTA 5 birthmark

GTA: Vice City
Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven
Fallout: New Vegas
Alien vs Predator 2
Morrowind

Indeed the games are full but of the favorite Crisis and Metro, WORLD, Left4dead, yes you can count for a long time. Now he's on the http://www.dragonknight.ru/. Mmm... still Dead island and Homefront, generally games full of fun, the main thing is not to forget to play in life)))) well, or at least to come off to eat))

Hmm... Many of them have been killed in the GTA 3, including me.

Silent hill 1,2,3,4 , Skyrim

In my opinion, games more elaborated to the smallest detail, i.e. the mission can be passed in many ways (as in life, the problem can be found many solutions) remain the games Fallout 1 and 2 !! For in these games I played a very large amount of time in my youth, they were driven far and wide, and I have no doubt that including one of them now and a little playing I will find something else unknown ... And yes these games really immerse in the atmosphere of post-nuclear war ...
That's my opinion...

Don't Starve

Well stalker, subway, skyrim. That's what I particularly liked.

From the latter: Ori and the Blind Forest and Wolfenstein: The Old Blood.

1 Mafia II
2 S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear skies
3 Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, The
4 Fallout 1 and 2
5 Skyrim

Bloodborne (strange that no one named), Alone in the Dark 2008, Majesty 2, Skyrim

For me, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. has become, will remain, and will always be the best and most atmospheric game. This, unique atmosphere, memorable plot, the story of the shooter. Stalker clear sky - a cool prequel Shadow Chernobyl, where tell how it all began ... Believe me, it is difficult to put into words ;)
And when I turn on the music (well, the one that Sidorovich plays) I close my eyes, imagine the zone, sometimes even to tears I get.

[S.i.d.a.k.r.i.s.]
I agree with you, brother stalker :)