Imagine the situation ...
Imagine a situation in which, by the way, anyone can find themselves.You are at a consultation at a heart transplant center and you decide who will receive the only healthy heart.
Not an easy choice, but nonetheless.
You have a list of 10 patients who need a transplant, you need to choose one.
1. Man, 29 years old. Businessman. Can provide financial support to the clinic.
2. Girl, 10 years old. Mentally retarded. Suffering from cerebral palsy.
3. Woman, 62 years old. Mother of six children.
4. Man, 33 years old. Leader of the Jehovah's Witnesses religious sect.
5. Woman, 19 years old. Student. Repeated suicide attempts.
6. Man, 42 years old. Azerbaijani. Construction worker. Was injured while working in Russia.
7. Woman, 56 years old. Doctor-oncologist, develops new means of treating cancerous tumors. Lesbian.
8. Man, 37 years old. Deputy Minister of Finance, Jew.
9. Woman, 22 years old. Sportswoman, gold medalist, member of the Olympic curling team.
10. Man, 31 years old. Policeman, wounded during the arrest of a particularly dangerous criminal.
Choose one of the points (you can have several) and explain your choice.
Mayamenstate
SpoilerMy friend, you are sick,
You are terminally ill,
Your disease is called rock.
My friend, your hour is uneven,
Your soul will receive a time.
I don’t know any of them to make a choice in someone’s favor based on some feelings, so I will transplant, of course, to the one who will bring the greatest benefit to humanity.
Veenine wrote:
Any choice that is not based on the likelihood of a successful operation and not on a lot is considered unethical.
Agree. This is the only correct answer. +1
I would give an oncologist, even a lesbian, she still doesn’t pull the old ones, or the girl, because it’s just a pity, children’s children can also achieve a lot in life, but it would be logical for a cop, like it would be logical to transplant him, we have all the cops thumping and he may be on a raid was just drunk or under a spice, so no, it will cost, neh to throw under the bullets
To any of them, since I cannot know the consequences of the choice, which means that the chance that by extending the life of this particular individual, I will do something useful for humanity, is the same for everyone. For example, a suicide can jump under the presidential motorcade, as a result of which a car with a certain leader will jump off the bridge. The doctor may decide that he has had enough and will knit socks for the rest of his life, and the Azer, returning from a construction site, can drive away a pack of stray dogs from a six-year-old boy, in the future the inventor of jumpdrive. Anything is possible, that's why there is only a coin toss and nothing else.
A little girl who suffers from cerebral palsy has yet to live and has a great future
The famous creator of the jetboard, Frank Zapata, tried out the new invention of the Flyboard Air, now with a jet engine.
He flew over the lake, as there was a high probability of overturning, and the fuel tank behind his back only added danger.
The flight, during which Frank climbed to a height of 30 meters, was successful.
Wing42 wrote:
Well, who was cured of these ladies and gentlemen that are named in the list?
Male, 37 years old. Deputy Minister of Finance, Jew.
Either 7 or 10.
Just because they have a direct benefit, the rest will "survive", heh
1. The businessman will buy himself, there is some money.
2. Girl, controversial issue, but rather not.
3. I would bet a woman, she needs to raise and educate children.
4. The sectarian would definitely not put it)
5. A suicide and then he will kill himself)
6. I would not put Azeru either, he is an Azeri.
7.Lesbian, hmm, I think it's not worth it either. Passion will help.
8. Well, the Jew is definitely not.
9. Let the athlete sponsor the sponsors of the sport.
10. Well, in principle, the policeman can, if he is honest)