Silent Hill 2 vs. Silent Hill 4. What's scarier? (Silent Hill 4: The Room)

Why sobsno question is about comparing the 2nd and 4th parts? Personally, I think that SH3 is the scariest of the entire series. Not least because anyone with a drive is not necessary(always go alone, although walking with Mary in the second part I really liked was diluted with obstanovochka.On the other hand fearfulness minus 50% in half for no apparent reason=). In SH4 have not played - afraid... to be disappointed in the series -- why is it all the water know what. No joke, the SH2 in my personal hit parade is 1,2 and 3 place!!!

Dude , the question is about comparison all of the parts( the third of course is great ). Well I could not call the theme : Silent Hill vs.Silent Hill 2 vs. Silent Hill 3 vs. Silent Hill 4 .
But I still think that the second best part of the series , and the fourth is mediocre ( especially for beginners) , but I still was not over the passage quite scary .Although ,again , the fourth part doesn't suck .

2 scion
Don't be afraid of disappointment, maybe the game no one was called a failure (in any review, in any post here). All just agreed that she's different, different from the rest. Don't you wonder what she scored?:) Time causes so much controversy, so many contradictory comparisons.. is it says that it is not terrible? Horror to the hiccups you no promises, but what you a couple of times will turn the brightness to full, and the sound is on minimum - that's for sure!

Almost completely agree with Ghostboy ( only I'm not twisted - the game itself , BUT THIS is the FOURTH PART of SILENT HILL ! And that's it .
PS SH 4 pulls 5 points on a 12 point scale.

Hi all. I played all the SH and I think they are all very successful. Undoubtedly, the Japanese are one step ahead of the world in terms of creating horror movies, yet they have a special way of thinking. Try to perform part of the game.
First I played a little with the settings of the emulator, but it is felt that at the time the game exciting. I actually always wondered how Konami has been able to draw Europeans.
On the second you can say a lot, I liked her the most, however, to compare it with others I wouldn't, all the parts are just very different. James I loved my girlfriend very sick. Fortunately, now nothing happened, but a year ago, when I was constantly waiting for the fateful news from the hospital, Silent Hill 2 is literally supported me, not allowing to break. I went through all the endings, and I felt much better, though, since I almost did not touch, as emotionally this theme for me is exhausted, and the action component, I inohara immediately. Only play at the beginner level, and I can say that it is much better than on hard, although can go on easy. just easy able to concentrate on the meaning.
By the way, I am sure that to remove such a film is quite real, and as for violence, you can do without it, because it is not a scare monsters, indeed! The only problem is that to remove it will probably be the Japanese, and they hundred percent will do very much violence than actually bury the idea of the film for the rest of the world. Who saw the battle Royal, filmed by Takeshi Kitano, he certainly remembers all the killings, but hardly explain why the school teacher who stabbed to death his class in the 42 pupils, however, gave one girl the umbrella so she wouldn't get wet in the rain. To understand all this, you have to forget that all the characters in the film the gun in his hand. Americans may be better served, for the main roles you could take, for example, Kyle MacLachlan from twin peaks or there, I don't know, John kusaka from Identification and Air Prison.
The third part of SH to me quite amused, but too much. Heather Mason, of course, the girl that is necessary, sorry, it in reality does not exist, although I have read that the virtual Heather has some gear on one of the Japanese channels. What are her movements, gait, manner of warfare, I just kind enjoyed. It was literally the other silent hill. Music should be humorous, like Into wonderland or Family Man written by Mike Oldfield, or the Load was supposed to give one to Melissa. Heather is very confident and felt like she had Offspring in the headphones sounded. And some comments are worth to saw bloodied rabbit in the night Park, to blurt out something sarcastic - that any gamer will be forced to fall off the chair and bend on the floor in hysterical laughter.
Don't get me wrong - I moved on to the third part from the second, which was a very long time, so for me this meant simply relax. Yes, horror has gone, but the whole point of horror is that it disappears, otherwise it just becomes boring and dies. The best in the third part, in my opinion, is that the second third of the game is satire still gives way to fear, and the third fear is replaced by determination, no longer be afraid of myself and start to worry for the girl. Realize that love is far beyond any fear. Indeed, from all four parts of the third best of all helps the player to understand, what are we afraid of and why. And I wouldn't say that the game is too short, I have it in the first pass made over five and a half hours without prohodilo, while the second only three.
Quests are good, they still have logic, it's just, again, Japanese. I immediately realized that the camera needs to be somewhere to look, like the Cabinet or the screen - and so it happened. Techniques like burn the meat in the bucket and singe picture - of course, remember, it's very well done.
Tired of only design levels, it bores me in all parts. For example, I am not afraid of blood, and the walls sprinkled with a couple of tanks of red liquid, make me yawn. Shopping center in a nightmarish reincarnation, comrades, it's not for the Soviet people made! I understand that for Americans, not to mention the Japanese, just a dirty store with rust appearing already looks terrifying, but we are used to, and these levels to me looked just like the utility room of our municipal theater, if they turn off the light. Alternative temple, on the contrary, too much, when all bloody so that you can focus only on the map.
Complete contradictory picture of the show-off kind of endless flamethrower, beam sword and pornographic costumes And the plot is stupid at all, as in the Mexican series. The final boss in the second part was much better. There's even a storyline, in principle, is not over after beating the game, it was the only in the video, and here to prove the truth and combat the Supreme link of the entire horror quiet Hill was able to use precise strike with a hammer on the head. And why all this lofty talk about the deity of hatred, love, feelings - all issues resolved trite, Hollywood.
So the third part, I generally took lightly, and I think it was right.
Fourth. Damn, do none of you noticed that in the fourth there is no radio, no flashlight? I've tried and the stereo in the apartment of Henry apart, and each lamp looked - nothing. Henry liked me too, but he, unlike Harry Mason and James Sunderland, doesn't look a victim of circumstances, a sort of modest macho that American films are on the sidelines, a loyal friend and physically strong man with blue eyes. About James I could not say what he does, what life in General is engaged, and Henry is probably a stripper. Eileen nothing, so every school has. The plot was a pleasant surprise, a real detective novel. About repulsive monsters - clearly a mistake of developers, first, you need to distinguish the terrible from the ugly, are completely different things, I never even do not watch movies where they show a giant smelly rats and similar stuff, Stephen king ninety percent of the books just because this shit is, and they, thank God, in our countries is almost unknown. Secondly, the style of Henry, his appearance, demeanor does not tally with the fact that he can kill monsters impossible. Right here a massive fight would not hurt the atmosphere of the game. This Latinoamerica Cynthia is also a good addition to Henry, but her Ghost is more like the girl from the ring, of course, also Japanese.
By the way, I note that children in all parts of the game do not see anything dreadful, they are obvious, the juxtaposition of the dark, only the light leave yourself, and you don't give it to the player. I expected more from the role of children in Silent Hill.
Locations are not annoyed because they are quite logical. The method of contact to the kitchen in the prison - again, this is a purely Japanese thing, symbolizing integrity. It's simple: the prison doors should never be opened! They should be, to remind us that out in theory, but in fact it is impossible, after they will lock accidents, which is constantly watching. Better to let the floors rotate to dump corpses - it's so literary! The forest looks more like a Park would be better if it didn't break the levels, and did as the second part is a small visible continuous space, drawn with great quality. And so, the fourth part of all there is no open levels. Not only liked the big zashtampovannost locations - subway, prison and hospital, it's like in shooters, sewers and rooms with crates. The forest still saves the game from a vague sense of the presence of certain patterns in the design rounds.
Back to monsters - I, when the hospital saw a three-meter beasts, could not resist and looked into prohodilku to know what they are called. When I learned that this nurse had a big laugh. Dogs are cool when they scream Wow!... after hitting a pipe, I expect they will add ...I feel good!
And music, I really have not heard, unlike the second part, where she constantly acted to the fore.
That seems to be all. To sum up, will not - it's still early, and there is no need. All the while!

Well done - not lazy so much namasket ! Good thinking.

We have no female gamers on PG.Respect to you,Russell.

Silent Hill 4 - the scariest part of all that was... you Know... how would you better explain...
First you played in Сх1 or the CX2, the difference is a special present, in those parts in which you first played.. they leave a lot more emotion and excitement than all the rest later... you Know, it's like the first kiss, he remembered always.... So I personally played the first 4 part( generally with a series of CX, I was a stranger, but when I played part 4, by the way, I have not yet passed, the current is started the 2 half, and the fear I was in shock,I became a real fan of this game and then bought 2 and part 3 ),I felt the flow of the atmosphere... you can't describe it... but you write quite the contrary... well, is it possible? This is not a game but a MASTERPIECE! The rest of the parts compared to her bullshit huh? Okay I confess... part 2 is also a little scary! You say, 4 the monsters are not scary? Yeah when I saw the monster in part 2, I'm not scared.. I laughed... it was some kind of polygon right! Of course, I thought so after game part 4! And in part 2 violated the element of surprise, and he should be in any horror film, this effect is ruining music, or radio from James, when showing up near the monster. And you after all this, I assure you that part 2 worse? Heh.. it's funnier! When I heard the hiss of a radio, or the music, I expected to see, or again a copy of the thread monster, or a new polygon plate, and quite Nebojsa! Say it again, 4 parts of fear more than 3 or 4 times! Part 2 was terrible... maybe when it came out, and it was long ago, but if you now play the game, complete bullshit, especially after 4 pieces! You think it's worse than remembering the days when she was maybe scary, but now, compared with the 2 part, 4 part is just awful, next to the comics! Unfortunately, so many judge! But I only made one good lesson, never to trust the opinions of others!
Just ask anyone who first played in Сх4, and then all the rest, he would say that 4 is the most terrible, as it is now I'm saying to you, and you think the opposite, the reason I have described above! All the best!

SH2 - the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ps: sh3 - too anything...

Each part is a corner. All the parts are different.
1 part - a Horrible Nightmare (it was not even clear what's what)
Part 2 - Psychic Nightmare (consciousness CH. hero on the first cast)
Part 3 - Disgusting Nightmare (Blood Blood Blood!!! Clear phobia of childbirth in depth of the heroine)
Part 4 - Claustrophobically Nightmare (Staring out the window endlessly)

And music I not only liked the 3rd part. Hollywood it kind.

the second part I zaglyuchil by the piano, the fourth struck the poor graphics, but the third part is something unearthly. I only played a day and not one..............

People, let's face the truth. Why is everyone so respect CX 2? Yes, because it was the first creation of this type on the PC. But now, after 4 of part I CX 2 remember only with a smile. Well, what was there terrible people? These poor pyramid head? Do not tell! And the plot? Husband looking for his wife... nothing more Banal could come up with? Then all this eating and privatively, because it was not analog... But now, I again returned during the first CX when the hero gradually zagadivat the mystery of dark city while searching for his daughter. In CX 1 in the foreground was a secret city, not the personal problems of some James. In silent hill 4 is also the story of a super - ritual murder and its solution. Now I understand why the hero enters this world, he has no choice!!! But you rushed into a sinister bloody city alone (CX 2), even in search of his beloved wife? Huh? Here is the story! Someone will say, the same garbage was in SH 1. No, favorite. At first there were only dogs and unknown birds. And then the city just let the main character, gradually bringing it to its grim history. I'm not praising CX 4. The solution is almost all the secrets in the middle of the game simply negates the second part of CX 4, but the first is a masterpiece! Also I haven't played SH 3. But I can confidently say - CX 2 - the weakest part. No shit it is terrible there!

666 - Man, about the same I wrote above! Silent Hill 4: The Room - the scariest part of all... One word toklko The Room name is already part of a certain mystique... and fear... to be Honest, in the first half of the game, I wanted to stay longer in his apartment, it was quiet..And when I wandered on these horrible worlds, I wanted to come home... but then everything changed.. namely in the second half of the game... I just didn't want to go back home...As the current I went back there... I run to survive and immediately to the bath - hole, away from home... until the end of the game I still did not pass... although I bought it long time ago... How current I bought it, I barely reached the second half of the game, all in a cold sweat... then stopped playing.. I bought the CX2, like I thought it would be more correct, first to play in the CX2,3, and then 4 that everything was in order, besides, I heard that 4 of the characters associated with the other parts...And then I started to play in the 2 part...to be Honest, when I saw the first monster that shoal light on the street... I laughed... But then when I started to enter the house, wander through it, was really scary... but not as much as in СХ4.. after completing the CX2, I of course started СХ3, in General I would say, I started... and finished...I was just not interested in playing in СХ3 fiction... there is no story(Or I just do not glidel )... besides, I have the game СХ3, was no sound on the videos, which makes the game even more uninteresting.. the main thing in a series of Silent Hill games? That's right - the plot! First the story, then everything else... So СХ3, I passed can be between 3% of the game, and abandoned it... started СХ4 to go again... First I bought it 2 Diabetes, but later I was told that 2 diabetes, no commercials and all sorts of secrets - they cut.... Bought 4 SD, and really, everything, and videos..and all I didn't 2 diabetes, so who knows I must warn you, if you decide to buy СХ4, then take the 4 SD and not the 2!

MCFool - I Agree 100! That feeling when you return to your home shelter (room 302) from the warped someone's sick mind of the world in the first part, and when you run out of favorite room (even want to call her mom :-)) hell, it doesn't matter where - just do not pass! And if someone is not seen then sense - I feel sorry for him. By the way, I want to ask - and what, in addition to clips, there's 2 CD? I understand that the appearance in the basement of the second prison of the Ghost of the murdered, then the Ghost of a neighbor, and the entrance to the room with the hanging monsters (well, where it is necessary to choose the right) must be accompanied by the commercials, right? Is it worth it for them to buy 4 CD? Or is there something else interesting?

666 - I can't tell... because, the game on the 2SD, I did not pass... I got current up to half... and 4 SD, too, wait current has reached half.... well what can I say... firstly on 2 SD is not the main splash movie - and he's cool.... And anyway... there is fiction and there might be history starting.. because when starting the game, there rasskazyvaetsya that and what happened to Henry, at 2 diabetes there might be no word of fiction... Yes, you're right, in every world, someone dies, and then when you 2 once I walk these worlds with Eileen, those who have died in the worlds, becoming animism ghosts here, for example, in the subway died some kind of beauty when you 2 never go to subway, it is already there flies like a Ghost and this time when I meet her Ghost followed by video....Also in all the worlds.... And what about the secrets also can not say, because no one ever found.... but I was told that the type of secrets 2SD either.... And the secret is there might be different types of clothes... and something else... I do not...
So in any case I suggest you to take 4 diabetes...... By the way dude.. I don't remember exactly... but I think when I played the 2 DM in the game I have to the 2nd part of the game was a few candles, and medallions... and play now, found a locket and all.... If you got to the 2nd half, a cha Lope candles and medallions were?

MCFool - I don't remember. I also itray second time (accidentally wiped my save game), got to the hospital too, or a single candle! Advise them to be careful, as I once tried to put this in the room where the ghosts were - and... died!!! Here are the candle!

666 - Just passed СХ4.. first look not very good ending - Eileen died, but the demons I cast out, and the ending was so, I again Wake up in his apartment, get up..come to radio.. they say news type were found dead and one still alive, a woman named Eileen Galvin was taken to the hospital,where later she died....I scream Eileen!! And camera opuskaetsya down on the floor (View during all this time the house was still 1 person). Also saw the best of the demons was banished, and she survived, the ending is this - I'm leaving his house, walking on the street, then come to the hospital to see Eileen with flowers, and she said, what type we'll have to find another place to live..... Now I want to see the remaining 2 endings to see them I guess I'm just not shanati any of the demons that they remain in the house, then I see two more, it will be - I not cast out demons but Aylin survived - not very bad, and I didn't cast out demons and Eileen died - the worst ending in the game!
Actually, who went through the whole game, at least understand the story and what's the point? If not, then I will explain... in Short, in the same room 302, in the same house, long before he settled into it, Henry, and Joseph, lived there for a certain couple... Yes a couple, they have a son.. which they refused still in the hospital... then when he's a little older, he was sent to a home for orphans called Wish House (wish House - you have already been in the woods), but in actual fact, it was no ordinary orphanage.... it was some religious cult, hiding from the orphanage where the children were poisoned brains wcss stuff... And that's little Walter, having lived there... soon began to think that his mother is room 302...Sometimes he went to the house to see her... the road was very long, he had to travel by bus,and other transport, but he did it more and more often, and soon the residents of the house did not like, namely those who lived in this very room 302, and the tenants began to say to him after that little Walter was to see in them an obstacle to meeting with the so-called mom....Uh... more like was how Walter grew up, and learned who his real mother all this time when ROS Walter, the cult managed very well to cloud his brain, and Walter was... uh ... I kind of don't remember.. toli he was very secretive and didn't like people.. toli still that, in short, he learned who his real mother and learned how to bring it back... he found out about the 21 dinner, so to execute it, we had to kill 21 the sinner.. Then his mother will voskresnet.. or something like that.. and it started to work.... he killed so, despatched the victim, he was removed from the body of the heart, and vyrezal on her digits, the order of the murders,he wrote 01121 so that meant 1\21, like the first of the 21 one, and so in order... he killed and killed.. but after the 10 victims he was caught by the police... put his... soon discover that Walter had committed suicide in his cell, sticking his throat with a sharpened spoon... and writing for yourself 11121, which meant 11\21, the type itself is also counted... (this surprised me)..All.. the killings stopped... for a while...But soon.. as it is not enough, they continued... the Police thought that the case of the fan of Walter or something like that, because the murders were very similar...there was only one difference - the heart of the victim were in place, and numbers were still awartani on the victims....Uh... like what happened... wait remember....In short, in Sammy house, to the room seleena new tenant, a Henry Townshend,the protagonist. 28. The secretive nature. Not married. He lived there a week... and then came... the Nightmares... and always had the same dream that we are given to see and even stroll it at the beginning of the game. One day she woke up from another nightmare, Henry discovers its input drew, someone did a very good job - It was closed many circuits which do not allow him to open the door, same with Windows - they are clogged and not otkryvayutsya matter how he tried, the phone doesn't work - someone cut the cable TV, too.. Henry found himself in a trap, unable to get out of your own apartment (Although I do not know if it is all so bad, why not just simply break the window with something? For example, the same metal pipe)...All that Henry is, it just doesn't make any sense to look out the window, peephole in the front door and also doesn't make any sense to watch his neighbor Eileen...after Living a little of this, Henry soon discovers that in the bathroom there was some kind of strange hole...which because of the desperate situation he naturally climbs and okazyvaetsya - but we started to play СХ4, from the moment that Walter (or someone like him), has managed to kill al 15 victims we are given to see how he raspravlyaetsya with the last remaining six sinners, and as we all remember 16121 the victim is the pretty lady that you met on the subway, 17121 - is this the dude from the forest that burned, 18121 is the man from the water prison, 19121 is another man of the world.. damn how it is called? Short of the city, and the last 2 is the Eileen and Henry, which will be difficulties=-) And I want to see what all the victims of Walter killed escuchalo those who lived in this house... here's an example to Henry in room 302, was a Joseph, who by the way was speaking 10121 victim, and which during the game will give you different kinds of information, he could not escape... And so sum up - your task is not to give Walter to complete the 21 lunch... And now the facts that I do not understand:
1) - If Walter wanted Henry was in his apartment and quietly waited for their turn, why give him the opportunity to go to worlds where they can suck from others,he will try to save them, thus somehow interfering with Walter to kill them.
2) - How connected home Manager Sunderland, James Sunderland from the CX2?
3) - Why the other victims of this house not locked? For example, tighter Eileen, she could easily move around the city, and she must die too...
4) - Why little Walter helped Eileen to survive when approached her hour and big Walter wanted to kill her?
5) - How could it be that the little and big Walters was found together? It's not 2 different people!Yes, initially it was small, but then grew up, that's all..
6) - What the hell nesetsya in one note? It's about a boy and his mother who were tied with magic rope, but then she broke, and mom's asleep...It's about what they say anyway?
7) How were these organnye worlds of the other characters? For example, the same Eileen? Because they have no holes in the flats!
8) - Why the Manager of Sunderland, he kept the umbilical cord Walter? Make sense?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And anyway.. if you think so.. then Walter is not so bad... the Vedas, he was killed for a reason,not for entertainment, but because of his mother, whom he loved dearly....
If you have answers to the questions, or do you have something to add to the story or just to correct me, write!See you soon!

www.silenthill.ru

666 - MCFool Eco sausage you why so about the plot to grovel? It seems to me, who have brains - he would have to guess... :-) Below are your guesses for your questions:

1) All the victims were in fact killed in the other world, and therefore Henry had to be there and will it interfere with or wait to die - his business.
2) Sunderland - namesakes, well at best - relatives, and no connection I have not noticed.
3) walked around the city not only Eileen, if in the game beginning to look out of the window - near the metro will be a beauty that will kill you later.
So the choice of victims was not - anyway they were sucked into another world, whether locked or not.
4) Perhaps little Walter still wasn't mentally shifted and therefore could not tolerate murder, for example. How do you release? The question is HOW did he prevent adult Sullivan???????????????
5) who the hell knows how could Walters vstretitsa! It's silent hill! Everything is possible. I have a hunch, will write later.
6) Mother, son, and rope - it's about the birth of Walter and figuratively on communication with the apartment, I guess...
7) If you remember CX 1 - to be transported to another world even sleep was not necessary. Everything happened in real-time. Perhaps there is a parallel... and maybe hole was a clear answer in the game not.
8) the Manager is a pervert! The other answer can not find. Or maybe a lover of the series X-fails! :-)

Now my question is: how Walter survived and what he became after the suicide? After all, the victim 11/21 - he!!! Here perhaps the answer about splitting Walter: a boy - Walter to suicide, which is still in doubt (when he saved Eileen), man - a creature that will not stop - too far gone (including suicide or whatever it was).

If you noticed something interesting - write, communicate.

I haven't played in any part, I just
listened to a few soundtracks from Silent Hill 2, but judging by the information I managed to dig up on the Internet (about 1 GB), chetvertaia plays second throughout.