3 New Notifications

New Badge Earned
Get 1K upvotes on your post
Life choices of my cat
Earned 210

Drag Images here or Browse from your computer.

Trending Posts
Sorted by Newest First
_
_FIL_ 25.11.21 12:20 am

Gothic 3 vs Gothic 2 (Gothic 3)

I just thought the second would be cooler, especially for its time (to be politically correct I will add that IMHO)))). The plot is not so linear there.
And in general, where did the inscriptions on the graves go, like "I lay down to rest a little ...". Yes, yes, I liked to read them)))
162 Comments
Sort by:
S
Stanly ii 25.11.21

Gothic 3 will not immediately please. But if you open all the chests, forge the best swords and go through, it may even be a lot of fun (no cheats. It's a pity that you can't get the best staff of Invincibility for a magician :( :)) There are no inscriptions on the graves - they did not pay attention to much.
Babies from 1 to 12 months love to be held back, which is why they are wrapped up so tightly - this gives them a sense of comfort and security.
When I grew up not so good, they say "Oh, where are you, my childhood (or young years)." It becomes a lot of responsibilities, very much, and it seems that before it was much better than now. You just do not have time to be content with the present.
As well as gothic. In the first one we were restrained by a (small :) Barrier, we were still quite weak and defenseless. Then the childhood of Gothic 2, the adolescence of G2NV. And for the third, we are already independent and adult individuals with direct responsibilities, all the time talking "where my childhood was, it was good, warm and comfortable" about Gothic 1,2. This is one life and the continuation of the series. Perception did not begin to attach importance to the little things, as it did in the past. Nobody wants to grow up? :)
Of course I don’t want to, but when they understand, Gothic 3 will open for them and this disappointment, the feeling will disappear.

R
RDream 25.11.21

Gothic 2 is definitely better for its time and even now, but only for connoisseurs of a good plot and excellent gameplay, and of course the atmosphere (of course, for those who care about graphics and the engine as a whole, this is not the case)

ps
music in Gotha first and second is not discussed at all.

In Gothic 3, freedom is very conditional, and because of this freedom, you can finally miss the game. I didn’t care about the system requirements; my 3 part flies on moxa without brakes. I liked the music in the second part more. The gameplay and atmosphere, as well as the coloring of the characters, the dialogues, the plot, the pumping system, and finally the combat system, which in 3 parts turned into a stupid slasher, I liked much more in Gothic 2. Still in 3 parts there is an unbreakable character diary in which instead of the goals and thoughts of the character what he thinks about this task, the dialogue between the GG and the npc is now recorded - what kind of nonsense. For me, the graphics in the game are not important - I still play fallout 2. Oh, and the ending of some of the storylines of certain characters did not really appeal to me - here's an example,

ps The

addon for the second part was a masterpiece (nights of the raven) and the addon for the third was a gross fake.

G
GeneralLee 25.11.21

r1 in my opinion is just a masterpiece! even if there is no non-linearity, beautiful graphics and convenient controls ... but there is an interesting, addictive, bewitching plot! which is not the first time))
r2 + HB is a worthy continuation of its predecessor! although not so masterpiece!
I can’t say anything about r3 ((I downloaded 2 times, installed it, played for 1-2 days and scored ... well, I don’t catch the igruha in any way .. such a feeling that the developers have outplayed morovind ((many factions for everything, play and complete all the quests ... atmospheric 1 and 2g ... such a feeling that
I am not oblivion!

T
Tigrenok123 25.11.21

I bet on the third, in it at least you can win the first battle!

B
Bunny 23 25.11.21

I like Gothic 2 more than Gothic 3

S
Shade eric 25.11.21

all the goths oh!
how can you compare them ?? each of them has its own unique flavor!

But if you still compare, then I choose r2 + addon Return)

a
artemik331 25.11.21

if there were no brakes in Gothic 3 and had the same combat system as in the second, I would say that it is better

s
simple.user 25.11.21

oooh yeah! Yes! Yes! thanks for Temko!

Get ready. Now you can contemplate a miracle of a rare species - in this topic, right before your eyes (!), Holivor and flame will begin! 111
-
So, let's start with the merits of this "masterpiece" ... ummm, a masterpiece ... a curve of mediocrity called G3. Rejoice!
• You will spend more than one hour chatting with friendly funny bears in raincoats and sweatshirts, called orcs! And who came up with such a stupid name?
• An expansive world where complete freedom of action awaits you! But in reality we constantly have to look for a mythical guru. What kind of guru, who is he, where from ... And we are looking for him day after day ... In the game settings, on the forums ... And his mother is so, even if there were no guru, in this "free" world all the same there is nothing else ... Maybe he is too free? ..
• You will have a happy opportunity to take part in collecting herbs for some paralyzed dolpaepe, unable to leave his cave and collect them yourself. It is so depressing and sad that the paralyzed dolpaep after the next such quest diligently presents you with tons of experience and money so that you don't cry and don't quit the game.
• Old friends survived! Now, in order, apparently, to make the game at least a bit more fun, they were made clowns !!!
• GG also looks like a clown. It's even more fun! Rejoice!
• No brakes, NOT YET! Ideal for almost any machine and system! This is what an office worker said about Klondike Solitaire. Unfortunately, this has nothing to do with G3.
• Destroying monsters gives experience! Yes, think about it. Incredible, I agree. Especially when you consider that paralyzed dolpaepy will give much more and you generally sneeze from monsters from a high bell tower for experience from monsters.
• The strongest monsters in the form of wolves and boars! You have never seen anything like this! Ten of these cannot be killed until the end of the game. And for them - only some pitiful 50-100 experience! What about the harder monsters? Oh, what can we expect from monsters with 500 experience?

Gothic 3. Hardcooor! Rejoice!
-
What about the pros of G2 ... And there is the only big plus - THERE IS NOT ALL OF THE ABOVE. The choice is yours, dear fellow prisoners and immigrants from under the Barrier.

S
Shifroval 25.11.21

* feyspalm.jpg *
Oh Innos, well, why .. -_- G3 is one thing, and G2 is quite another.

s
simple.user 25.11.21

Come on. I've done something like this before ... Nothing will happen. :)

G3 is one thing, and G2 is quite another.
I like these phrases. Well, the name is the same, what does it mean "different"? The other is Code. Even Tes - and that is not another.

D
Dragon danny 25.11.21

In G3 there are some glitches, though ...
But in Gothic 2 ... You can search, but even if you find it is not very much ...
Peace ...
Do you want to sleep? You at G2NV
Want to sleep? Complete G3 25 times and maybe you will succeed.
However, in any case, I like all the Goths. Just one more, the second even more, and the third a little less.
What do you like best ... it's up to you ...

S
Someone's Bot. 25.11.21

For me the second is better than the third. In the third there are a lot of bugs, but there is a big world.

S
Shingok 25.11.21

Both games are great.

M
Made of metal 25.11.21

Gothic 3, unambiguously, is the best ... if you count by bugs and stupidity. But Gothic 2 is the greatest project, if you count in plot, voice acting, atmosphere. Yes, and Gothic 1, too, nothing, the control is incomprehensible, but what a nostalgia after the Gothic 2 (all, in theory, on the contrary: D). When I saw Diego and he spoke to me for the first time, I ... burst into tears (no kidding!). plot and everything else.
In the meantime, we are waiting for Arkania ... to see what the true legend has become ..................

C
Crazy.Smile.Wood 25.11.21

Gothic 3, definitely. The atmosphere is not the same. You can't argue with that already. But she got even better ..

_
_Lord_ 25.11.21

Eh ... I have to create such a topic) * I look at the ceiling ...

B
Biopsych 25.11.21

THE SECOND IS BETTER ALL !!!

_
_Lord_ 25.11.21

DOLG 1
Oh, look at the post above ... the third is better! Then let's vote on those)

_
_Lord_ 25.11.21

Voters here -http: //forums.playground.ru/gothic_3/700310/

A
Argonatika 25.11.21

3.3, and again 3. I love complete freedom, gorgeous views and the feeling of a full-fledged world!